What guitar should I buy? – A parent’s guide

what guitar to buy_parets guide

Every child would at some point or another be interested in learning to play an instrument and guitars being well accessible, taking up little space and relatively affordable is a great choice for parents wanting their child to learn about music.

The most important factors to consider are:

 

  1. Your Budget

  2. Age of the student

  3. The student’s musical interests

 I have included some links to what I consider to be great instruments for the aspiring beginner guitarist at the bottom of this post. 

  1. Your budget

The dreaded budget is something we all have to consider in one way or another, and another extracurricular activity’s expenses may drive us up the walls! Luckily one can purchase an entry-level guitar for well under a £100.

  1. Age of the student

Your child’s age will be one of the determining factors in deciding which guitar to buy for them initially. If the child is under 11 years of age, a ¾ size nylon string guitar will work great in most instances. As mentioned below, we are all different so always take your child to a music store first, put a guitar in his / her lap and determine how comfortable they feel with a particular size of the guitar.

  1. Student’s musical interests

Some young students may already know what music they are interested in playing. Listen to your child! If, for instance, he / she is listening to more rock orientated music it would likely be best to go with a steel string acoustic as opposed to a nylon string acoustic. He / she may even really prefer an electric guitar from the get-go.

Following is an in-depth look at various guitars for beginner students and some pros and cons regarding this. I would always recommend NOT buying something too expensive to start off with as we never know if they will persist in this endeavour. If they love it and want to upgrade in the future, then only the time will be right to buy something pricier.

  

Electric guitar or Acoustic guitar?

 

It is often asked if an electric (in need of an amplifier) or acoustic (able to produce good volume without amplification) would be best to start off with. (Below we take an in-depth look at the various types of guitars.)

In a nutshell, I personally think that it is better to start with an ACOUSTIC guitar. The biggest reason is that if you can play competently on an acoustic guitar you will be able to play competently on an electric guitar.

Unfortunately it is not always true the other way round. Because the acoustic guitar requires more strength in the hands than an electric guitar, a person who has only ever played electric guitar will find switching to acoustic guitar rather difficult. Conversely if an acoustic guitar player were to take up electric guitar, the transition is a lot easier on both the fingers as well as the brain.

Another reason I think it is better to start on an acoustic guitar is the price tag involved. One can purchase a very nice entry level steel string guitar for around £80. This is all the student really needs to practise and be able to learn. With an electric guitar one not only need the guitar (which start at around £70), but also an amplifier as well as cables.

This may not be too much of a concern, but saving a few quid when unsure if this will be a long-term endeavour, is always welcome.

Let’s take a closer look at various guitars to suit every child’s needs and get them inspired to play music!

 

Nylon string acoustic guitars

 

Nylon string acoustic guitar
Nylon string acoustic guitar

Nylon string guitars are usually the ‘go-to’ beginner guitar for children as the nylon strings are a bit more forgiving on the fingertips and largely recommended by guitar teachers and music shop sales assistants alike.

Because the strings are made of nylon (even the bass strings are nylon which is wound with copper or nickel alloy) they are softer on the fingers and relatively easy to produce a decent sound on. Nylon stringed guitars are generally called Classical Guitars or Spanish Guitars. They come in different sizes and the ¾ size is commonly recommended for younger children. The ¾ size guitar is obviously of smaller built, but also the neck is slightly narrower and shorter in length, making playing chords for small hands a lot easier! Because they are tuned the same as their grown-up brethren (with a longer neck length) the strings are not quite as tightly wound, again making it easier to press down on the frets to create different notes relatively easily.

These guitars are also very affordable and for this reason a great buy to get children up and going in their musical endeavours.

Young children will obviously outgrow a ¾ size guitar sooner or later but because of its relatively inexpensive price tag that’s not too much of a worry. They make great gifts to be passed onto younger brothers, sisters, cousins or friends! Also if the child has carried on learning the guitar for a few years and still are enthused, it is well worth investigating an upgrade anyway!

I would normally recommend a ¾ size guitar for young children up to around 11. Please remember that we are all different and that this recommendation is not written in stone!

If the child is a little older it would be most preferable buying a full size guitar. Now, because the child is older he or she might already have an inkling of what music they are interested in playing.

For this reason if your child shows interest in wanting to learn the guitar, I strongly recommend talking to them and trying to figure out what they are interested in.

If they are not too sure, again I would recommend a nylon string guitar for all the reasons stated above. However this time it should be a full size guitar. As their hands, arms and tendons are by this time more developed it is usually better to get a full size guitar to avoid having to upgrade in 6 months’ time. Entry level Classical or Spanish guitars are very affordable and make learning the guitar easier on the fingers.

  • Classical guitars in their purest form are used to play, well, Classical guitar. They create very nice mellow and warm sounds and are usually played by plucking the strings with the fingers of the picking hand. (The right hand for right-handed people)
  • As this is also called a Spanish guitar, traditional Spanish and Flamenco music is popularly played on this type of guitar. (Note that there are subtle differences between Classical and Spanish guitar, but easily ‘google-able’)

Have a look at these beautiful nylon stringed endeavours:

Andres Segovia – Leyenda by Albeniz

Paco de Lucía & Al Di Meola – Mediterranean Sundance

Sometimes children are surprisingly sure of what they want and what music they would like to be able to play. They may have gotten interested in Taylor Swift or Oasis and the likes and thus a steel string acoustic guitar would be best suited to their needs.

Steel string acoustic guitar

 

steel string guitar
Steel string acoustic guitar

The steel string acoustic is, believe it or not, strung with steel strings as opposed to nylon strings. The first two strings closest to the floor are unwound and called plain-steel strings, where the 4 strings closest to the ceiling are wound usually with a copper, zinc and brass alloy.

The steel string acoustic guitar has been traditionally used to play all kinds of Folk music and works very well for strumming chords around the camp fire! The neck is also slightly narrower than a Classical guitar making it a little easier to play open-string chords. However, the steel strings do bite! Because the strings are made of hardened steel and are strung quite tight, it takes more force to push down on the strings making the fingers feel the workout a lot sooner. Luckily we develop calluses quickly if we play 10-20 minutes every day, so the fingers should settle and be hardened very soon!

Steel string guitars are used for playing anything from Bob Dylan to Oasis, from Queen to Radiohead to Al di Meola. It is a mightily versatile instrument! As the student becomes more adept and comfortable in playing this guitar he or she will progress to learn a number of songs quickly as the repertoire is so vast and using very similar chords.

The steel string acoustic guitar is usually only found as a full size guitar and is a little dearer than nylon stringed guitars. You can find a very nice steel string acoustic guitar starting around £70.

I would recommend getting a steel string acoustic guitar if the child is a little older and shows interest in rock and pop music. As said before the steel string acoustic guitar is a very versatile instrument and one can produce all kinds of sounds and music on it. Have a look below at some remarkable feats on this instrument.

Tommy Emmanuel – Classical gas

Jon Gomm – Passionflower

Electric guitar

 

electric guitar
Electric guitar

The electric guitar needs an amplifier to produce louder sounds. Unlike the acoustic guitars above, and electric guitar frequently features a solid wooden body and for that reason weigh more than its acoustic brother.

It is also strung with steel strings but the strings themselves are a lot thinner than acoustic guitar strings. The main reason for this is that one of the most characteristic traits of an electric guitar is the ability to bend or stretch the strings. This produces blues and rock sounds that in general cannot be accomplished with acoustic guitars.

Sound is picked up by what is called… wait for it…. Pickups! It’s really just a coil with some magnets inside and this in turn picks up the strings’ vibration. The signal is then sent via a wire to an amplifier which amplifies the sound and then sends it out a speaker and into our unsuspecting eardrums. On the plus side, amplifiers have indeed got a volume control, so one can play it at low volumes, making it perfect for practising while having people over for tea!

For the reason that one needs an amp, this makes for a bit more of an expensive enterprise, but if the person is interested, a very cool endeavour indeed!

If your child is listening to more rock-orientated music it is well worth investigating buying an electric guitar!

Here are some of my favourite electric guitar moments:

Eric Johnson – Cliffs of Dover

Steve Vai – I Know You’re Here

 

In conclusion

My first guitar was a steel string acoustic and I believe that I would not have progressed as quickly as I did had I started on an electric guitar. It trained my fingers to be accurate and strong, so when I got my first electric it was a quick and smooth transition.

Nylon string guitars, steel string guitars and electric guitars are all tuned the same (in standard tuning), so if you know some things on an acoustic it is relatively easy making the switch to an electric guitar.

Again I would start with a guitar that is not too expensive and upgrade as the student progresses and their needs change during future years.

Below are some great beginner acoustic and electric guitars to browse!

Nylon string Classical guitars

Yamaha CS40 3/4 Size Classical Guitar – Natural – £81

Yamaha CS40 3/4 Size Classical Guitar - Natural
Yamaha CS40 3/4 Classical Guitar

Yamaha C40 Full Size Classical Guitar – Natural – £86.18

Yamaha C40 Full Size Classical Guitar - Natural
Yamaha C40 Full Size Classical Guitar

Ibanez GA5TCE-AM Classical Guitar Amber mirror with cutaway and pickup – £143.04

Ibanez GA5TCE-AM Classical Guitar Amber mirror with cutaway and pickup
Ibanez GA5TCE-AM Classical Guitar

Steel string acoustic guitars

Ibanez VC50NJP-NT Acoustic Guitar Jam Pack with Bag / Strap / Tuner / Plectra in Display Box Natural High Gloss – £70.29

Ibanez VC50NJP-NT Acoustic Guitar Jam Pack with Bag / Strap / Tuner / Plectra in Display Box Natural High Gloss
Ibanez Acoustic Guitar Jam Pack

Yamaha F310 Full-Size Acoustic Guitar Basic Start Pack (Natural) – £99

Yamaha F310 Full-Size Acoustic Guitar Basic Start Pack (Natural)
Yamaha F310 Full-Size Acoustic Guitar

Tanglewood Roadster Folk Acoustic Guitar TWR O Natural Matt – £139

Tanglewood Roadster Folk Acoustic Guitar TWR O Natural Matt
Tanglewood Roadster Acoustic Guitar

Tanglewood DBT SFCE Electro Acoustic Super Folk Pack Natural – £189.95

Tanglewood DBT SFCE Electro Acoustic Super Folk Pack Natural
Tanglewood DBT SFCE Electro Acoustic

Electric guitars

Stagg S300-SB Standard Electric Guitar – Sunburst – £93.60

Stagg S300-SB Standard Electric Guitar - Sunburst
Stagg S300-SB Standard Electric Guitar

SQUIER BY FENDER STRATOCASTER ARCTIC WHITE BULLET Electric guitars Stratocaster – £94.64

SQUIER BY FENDER STRATOCASTER ARCTIC WHITE BULLET Electric guitars Stratocaster
SQUIER STRATOCASTER

Ibanez Gio GRG170DX Black Night – £165

Ibanez Gio GRG170DX Black Night
Ibanez Gio GRG170DX

Line 6 Spider 4 IV 15 Watt Combo Amplifier

Line 6 Spider 4 IV 15 Watt Combo Amplifier
Line 6 Spider

Roland Cube 10GX Guitar Amplifier

Roland Cube 10GX Guitar Amplifier
Roland Cube 10GX

And the award for the best sounding small guitar amplifier I ever played on goes to:

Yamaha THR5 Guitar Amp

Yamaha THR5 Guitar Amp
Yamaha THR5